Call or Chat 24/7

Serving clients across Minnesota
with 13 convenient office locations.

Mediator vs. Divorce Attorney: Which Do You Need?

When getting divorced in Minnesota, you have options for navigating the legal process. The two main processes are mediation and litigation. Both have professionals who can help you through the process—divorce mediators and divorce attorneys. While both can be valuable resources, they serve different roles and are suited for different situations.

Divorce is a challenging process, both emotionally and legally. Many folks wonder, “Should I use a mediator for divorce?” “Is mediation a good idea for a divorce?” The answers depend on your unique circumstances. When determining the best path forward, it’s crucial to understand the different roles of a divorce mediator vs. a lawyer. 

The experienced Minneapolis divorce lawyers at Milavetz Law, P.A., explain the differences between a divorce mediator vs. an attorney, the circumstances where mediation or litigation makes the most sense, and how hiring a divorce attorney can be beneficial in both scenarios during this challenging time.

When Is Divorce Mediation a Good Choice in Minnesota?

Divorce mediation is a process where a neutral third party, the mediator, helps divorcing spouses reach agreements on issues like property division, alimony, and child custody. The mediator facilitates communication and negotiation but does not make decisions for the couple or advocate on either spouse’s behalf. Mediation is typically less adversarial and less expensive than litigation.

Mediation can be a good option for Minnesota couples with an uncontested divorce, meaning they agree on most major issues. It works best when both spouses are willing to cooperate, compromise, and prioritize an amicable resolution. Mediation allows for more flexibility and creative problem-solving compared to court proceedings.

So, is mediation a good idea in divorce? It can be under the right circumstances. Scenarios where divorce mediation may be appropriate include:

  • Short marriages with no children or complex assets
  • Couples who have already reached a consensus on key divorce terms 
  • Spouses committed to maintaining a cordial co-parenting relationship
  • Parties who wish to keep their divorce details private

Mediation can also be effective for couples who agree on major issues but need help sorting through the finer details. A skilled mediator can guide discussions, offer creative solutions, and help the parties find common ground. 

A divorce attorney can also serve as a mediator. However, an attorney serving in that role must act as a neutral third party. They will not advocate for either spouse or offer legal advice. 

Mediation can be quite productive when both spouses approach it in good faith and are willing to listen and cooperate. However, even in mediation, the spouses should consult their divorce own attorney for legal guidance and to protect their rights.

Mediation is not suitable for every situation. If there is a history of domestic abuse, substance addiction, or mental illness, the structured process of litigation may be safer and more appropriate than the informal setting of mediation. Also, mediation may not be advisable if one spouse is unwilling to disclose financial information fully or attempts to hide assets. In such cases, the formal litigation discovery process may be necessary to ensure a fair outcome. 

Finally, divorcing spouses who disagree on issues such as child custody and property division should consider litigation to resolve them.

When Should Minnesota Residents Hire a Divorce Attorney?

It is advisable to hire a divorce attorney whether your divorce is amicable or contested, even when the spouses pursue mediation. However, it’s crucial to have an experienced divorce attorney advocate for your best interests in contested divorces and those involving complex issues. The divorce lawyers at Milavetz Law, P.A., have the legal knowledge and negotiation skills to handle high-stakes disputes that arise during a marriage’s dissolution. 

So, when deciding between mediation and litigation, consider the complexity of your case. Litigation should be considered when divorcing spouses disagree on significant issues such as:  

  • Child custody, parenting time, and parental decision-making authority
  • Spousal maintenance, alimony, and child support payments
  • Division of valuable assets, real estate, and personal property 
  • Business ownership and valuation
  • Allocation of retirement benefits, pensions, and investments
  • Responsibility for marital debts and liabilities

Hiring a divorce attorney is essential in these situations to protect your rights and interests. Attorneys can use formal discovery procedures to uncover hidden assets, present compelling arguments in court hearings, and negotiate on behalf of their clients.

It is important to understand that divorce attorneys can serve in different capacities during the divorce process. An attorney can represent one spouse as an advocate, protecting their interests and negotiating on their behalf. In this role, the attorney is not neutral. Instead, they work to achieve the best outcome for their client. 

Alternatively, an attorney can act as a neutral mediator, facilitating communication and negotiation between spouses. In this role, the attorney does not represent either party but instead works to help the couple reach mutually agreeable solutions.

The key difference between a mediator and a divorce attorney is that a mediator is neutral and does not provide legal advice or advocacy, while a divorce attorney can provide legal guidance and representation.

Attempting to resolve a contested divorce through mediation without legal representation can be risky, as the mediator cannot provide legal advice or advocate for either party. Decisions made in a divorce can have long-lasting financial and emotional consequences, so proper legal guidance is essential.

In summary, when deciding between a divorce mediator and a divorce attorney, consider the following:

  • Mediation may be a good choice if you and your spouse agree on most issues and want an amicable, cost-effective process. However, it’s still advisable for each spouse to have their own attorney for legal guidance.
  • Hiring a divorce attorney is crucial to protect your rights and interests if you have a complex case or disagree on major issues like child custody or property division.
  • In some cases, you may benefit from a mediator to facilitate communication and a divorce attorney to provide legal advice and representation.

Consulting with an experienced divorce attorney can help you determine the best approach for your unique situation.

Another factor to consider when choosing between mediation and litigation is the potential for future disputes. Even if a couple reaches an agreement at mediation, there’s no guarantee conflicts won’t arise down the road, especially when it comes to co-parenting or changed financial circumstances. Having a skilled attorney draft a comprehensive settlement agreement can help minimize the risk of future legal battles.

Consult the Experienced Divorce Attorneys at Milavetz Law

If you are facing a complex or contentious divorce in Minnesota, the skilled attorneys at Milavetz Law, P.A. are here to help. With over decades of experience and 13 office locations across the state, Milavetz Law is well-equipped to handle even the toughest divorce cases. Our legal team will work tirelessly to protect your interests and achieve the best possible outcome for your unique situation. 

Don’t navigate the difficulties of divorce alone. Whether you need a mediator, a divorce attorney, or both, the experienced team at Milavetz Law, P.A., can guide you through the process and help you achieve the best possible outcome. 

Schedule a consultation with Milavetz Law, P.A. today by going online or calling 763-560-0000 to discuss your case and determine whether a mediator, a divorce attorney, or both are right for you.

Badge for Avvo Rating 10.0 Superb Top Rated Personal Injury
Badge for Avvo Client's Choice 2019 Personal Injury
Badge for Super Lawyers
Badge for American Association for Justice
Best Lawyers logo
Martindale-Hubbell Preeminent badge
Minnesota State Bar Association (MSBA) badge
Badge for Minnesota Lawyer Attorneys of the Year
FindLaw badge for Milavetz Injury Law, P.A.